Loading...
Loading...
Contributors:
Dataset URI:
10.5281/zenodo.22800560Derived data and supporting materials underlying the article "Beyond adsorption capacity: an evidence assessment of arsenic adsorbents for Bangladesh-relevant groundwater treatment". The study assessed a stratified sample of 150 primary arsenic-adsorption studies published between 2018 and 2026 against fourteen evidence indicators calibrated to Bangladesh-relevant groundwater treatment, and separately reviewed thirteen Bangladesh empirical treatment and implementation studies. This deposit contains the data behind every number, table and figure in the article. Contents README.md – deposit description, provenance and reuse notes MANIFEST.csv – file-by-file row counts and column descriptions data/ – derived CSVs: the evidence-coding matrix for all 150 studies, the qmax and capacity audit, the source-reporting discrepancy log, indicator coverage, threshold sensitivity, association statistics, the database search log, and the record-level title/abstract screening log for all 3,318 deduplicated records supporting_information/ – S1 Text and S1–S11 Tables as submitted figures/ – Figs 1–6 as submitted What is not included Statistical analysis code is not deposited. Software versions, random seeds and procedure settings are given in S10 Table so that each analysis can be re-implemented from the data here. Publisher PDFs of the source studies and the raw licensed database exports are not redistributed because third-party rights may restrict redistribution; every source study is identified by DOI in the deposited files. Provenance notes for reusers These are stated in the article and repeated here because they affect how the files should be read. Extraction was performed by one author with AI assistance at the value-retrieval stage; every field was verified by the author against the source text, and all indicator codings and audit decisions were made by the author. The title/abstract screening log is a retrospective reconstruction. It was carried out after the sample had been drawn and was not blind to sample membership, so it characterises the eligible pool rather than generating the sample. Of the 495 exclusions, 301 concerned records with no abstract in the frozen exports and therefore rested on the title alone; bounding sensitivities place the eligible pool between 2,108 and 3,124 records. The material-family classification was also applied retrospectively, by the fixed title-based rule specified in S11 Table. Reported source values are preserved as published. No value was silently corrected. Values failing a source-quality check are retained with the reason for their analytical treatment, so a reuser applying different inclusion rules can re-derive the analysis. These records concern the internal consistency of reported values against conditions stated in the same report; they are not findings about the materials themselves. Indicator codings record documented evidence, not material quality. "NR" means the evidence was not reported; "No" means it was reported and did not meet the threshold. Absence of evidence is not evidence that a material would fail in future testing. Counts describe the sampled evidence set and are not design-weighted prevalence estimates for the wider literature. Related article This dataset supports a manuscript under review at PLOS Water. The article DOI will be added to this record on acceptance. Note: Version 2 adds the Bangladesh evidence table, Bangladesh indicator coverage and Bangladesh-versus-global comparison files, inadvertently omitted from version 1
Keyword(s):
arsenic; groundwater; adsorption; Bangladesh; drinking water treatment; evidence synthesis..
MeSH Term(s):
Grants and Funding:
No Grants or Funding Data Available
Associated Publication(s):
No Associated Publication Data Available
Supplementary Data:
No Supplementary Data Available
Related Dataset(s):
No Related Dataset Data Available
The National Library of Medicine (NLM) provides information about biomedical datasets. Inclusion on an NLM Web page does not imply endorsement of, or agreement with, the contents by NLM or the National Institutes of Health. Learn more: NLM Web Policies (nih.gov)