Loading...
Loading...
Contributors:
Dataset URI:
10.5281/zenodo.23018174This archive contains the data, code, and intermediate results for the manuscript "Rate-Limiting Steps and Machine-Learning Prediction of Enzyme Turnover Numbers: A Benchmark Reanalysis Across 21 Enzyme Families" (Aktaş & Rahayu, submitted to the Journal of Biomolecular Structure and Dynamics). What the study does. Machine-learning models of enzyme turnover number (kcat) are reported to generalize poorly to enzymes unlike their training data. We ask whether prediction accuracy differs between enzymes whose rate-limiting step is chemical and enzymes whose rate-limiting step is non-chemical (for example, conformational change or product release), and whether any difference depends on model architecture. We reanalyzed the published predictions of five models (DLKcat, UniKP, EITLEM-Kinetics, CataPro, CatPred) for 22 enzyme families from the public EnzyArena benchmark. Twenty-one families were classified from independent literature evidence (16 chemistry-limited, 5 dynamics-limited); one was retained as uncertain and excluded from all tests. No model was trained or modified. Main results, as reported in the manuscript. In a precision-weighted, model-pooled analysis, chemistry-limited families showed higher Spearman correlations than dynamics-limited families for the two sequence-only models (p = 0.0012), but not for the two models with structural-type input (p = 0.63). The independence-respecting family-level comparison, which we treat as the primary basis for judging significance, was directionally consistent but not significant (Mann-Whitney p = 0.354; Cohen's d = 0.78). The model-pooled result weakens to non-significance when only the strongest mechanistic evidence is used or when the two largest dynamics-limited families are excluded. Model architecture, training data, and representation are confounded, so the results are consistent with, but do not establish, the proposed explanation. Contents.- `data/`: the three EnzyArena source files (unmodified snapshot, September 2026) and the original extraction script.- `scripts/`: `extract_all_families.py` (recomputes per-family Spearman rho for the 20 EnzyArena-derived families from the raw CSVs), `recompute_ak_ppo.py` (adenylate kinase and polyphenol oxidase), `sensitivity_analyses.py` (manuscript Tables 2, 4 and 5, pLM-axis regrouping, mixed-effects models), `compute_r2_full.py` (R² and RMSE), and figure scripts.- `final_audit_recomputations.py`: family-level tests, bootstrap, and leave-one-family-out analysis.- `results/`: per-family correlation files and R²/RMSE results. `results/legacy_17family/` holds superseded outputs from an earlier 17-family version of the analysis, kept for provenance only.- `figures/final/`: the six manuscript figures. `figures/legacy_17family/` holds superseded figures.- `README.md`: directory guide, run instructions, and a table linking each manuscript item to its source file. Data and licensing note. The EnzyArena repository (github.com/zishuozeng/EnzyArena) is MIT-licensed; the MIT license here covers the authors' code. We make no claim about the licensing of the underlying BRENDA- and SABIO-RK-derived data; please consult those databases' own terms. Known limitations.(1) For five families, EnzyArena holds several kcat campaigns; rho was averaged across campaigns and n is the total number of mutants, which may overstate precision (a sensitivity check is included). (2) For thymidylate synthase, EnzyArena contains no kcat row for the cited reference, so a kcat/Km row was used (a sensitivity check excluding it is included). (3) The mixed-effects model with crossed family and model random effects reports a non-positive-definite Hessian, so its standard error is approximate. (4) Figure scripts write to the authors' original working directory and need their output path edited before running.
Keyword(s):
MeSH Term(s):
Grants and Funding:
No Grants or Funding Data Available
Associated Publication(s):
No Associated Publication Data Available
Supplementary Data:
No Supplementary Data Available
Related Dataset(s):
No Related Dataset Data Available
The National Library of Medicine (NLM) provides information about biomedical datasets. Inclusion on an NLM Web page does not imply endorsement of, or agreement with, the contents by NLM or the National Institutes of Health. Learn more: NLM Web Policies (nih.gov)