Loading...
Loading...
Contributors:
Dataset URI:
doi:10.7910/DVN/32KRQMThe police exercise broad discretion, particularly over the use of force, some of which is excessive. Literature on excessive use of force generally attributes its causes to either rotten apples, referring to individual officers prone to violence, or rotten barrels, which pertain to stable institutional factors. We argue that explanations straddling both themes—such as commanding officers—remain a neglected explanation for excessive use of force. Using three-way fixed effects modeling and variance decomposition on data from the New York Police Depart ment spanning 77 precincts across 2003-2020, we assess the impact of command ing officers on use of force across five outcomes: total force, suspicion-based force, misdemeanor force, unproductive force, and civilian allegations. Leveraging the NYPD’s systematic rotation policy, we find that commanding officers explain 6.8-13.7% of variance across outcomes, controlling for precinct and quarter-year fixed effects. Robustness tests support the variance decomposition. We conclude that police leader selection should be a priority in reducing excessive use of force.
Keyword(s):
MeSH Term(s):
Grants and Funding:
No Grants or Funding Data Available
Associated Publication(s):
No Associated Publication Data Available
Supplementary Data:
No Supplementary Data Available
Related Dataset(s):
No Related Dataset Data Available
The National Library of Medicine (NLM) provides information about biomedical datasets. Inclusion on an NLM Web page does not imply endorsement of, or agreement with, the contents by NLM or the National Institutes of Health. Learn more: NLM Web Policies (nih.gov)