Loading...
Loading...
Contributors:
Dataset URI:
10.5281/zenodo.23079623Description This dataset inventories the federal programme streams and regulatory instruments that finance or mandate urban ecological governance in the United States, and codes each on three dimensions: where the obligation to spend originates, whether the programme funds any mechanism connecting ecological evidence to planning decisions, and what happened to it during the 2025–2026 funding reversal. The inventory is not a ULE scoring record and does not apply the ULE scoring scale. It examines the E5 condition — epistemic translation — from the funding side rather than the jurisdictional side, and it treats the 2025–2026 reversal as a natural experiment: one external shock applied simultaneously to fourteen programmes whose legal designs differed. Why this inventory exists Analyses of US climate finance typically record funding volume. This inventory records funding architecture. Between 2022 and 2024 US cities received the largest federal climate investment in their history. Between 2025 and 2026, executive action, budget reconciliation, rescissions and the ordinary appropriations process removed much of it. What was removed and what survived did not divide by programme size, agency or policy area. The inventory is structured to make the line that it did divide along legible and testable. Coding scheme Two of the three codings were assigned independently of each other, from different evidence. The durability coding and the outcome coding carry the principal finding; the evidence-integration coding records an absence and is reported as such. durability_class — where the obligation to spend originates Class · Definition L1 Statutory or judicial anchor — The obligation arises from a court order, consent order or permit condition and does not depend on an annual appropriation decision L2 Standing institutional anchor — The obligation arises from a standing partnership agreement or formula allocation: appropriation-dependent, but recurrent and institutionally held L3 Appropriation-contingent — The programme rests on an annual or multi-year appropriation that an appropriations decision can end L4 Project-contingent — The programme rests on a competitive award cycle and ends when the award ends Assignment is made from the authorising instrument named in statutory_basis, not from the programme's size, duration or perceived stability. e5_level — does the programme fund evidence integration? Level · Definition 0 None — The programme funds no mechanism connecting monitoring findings to planning decisions 1 Partial, compliance-bounded — An evidence-revision cycle operates, but remains inside a regulatory compliance chain and does not reach planning authority 2 Required — The programme requires that ecological evidence reach planning decisions Assignment is made from the presence or absence of a funded feedback mechanism in programme documentation, without reference to the durability class. outcome_2025_26 — what happened during the reversal Value · Definition Survived unaffected — Continued without interruption through the reversal Active but proposed for cut — Operating, but proposed for reduction or elimination in the FY2026 budget request, or with its permanent authorisation removed from agency budget justifications Paused, terminated, repealed or closed — Disbursements paused, awards terminated, statutory basis repealed, or the programme effectively closed to new applicants Version 2 — what changed and why Three programme streams carried an e5_level of 1 in version 1 and are coded 0 here: the standing federal-municipal research partnerships, the IRA Environmental and Climate Justice Block Grants, and the HUD Community Development Block Grant. The rationale recorded for each at the first pass described what the programme permits rather than what it operates — a standing institution "without a formal planning-feedback mandate", capacity-building components that "can support governance infrastructure", and a structure that "permits funding governance infrastructure, though the programme does not require it". The codebook sets level 1 at an evidence-revision cycle that operates. None of the three describes one. What has been corrected is the application of the definition, not the definition itself, which is unchanged and published separately. The two streams left at level 1 — EPA consent decrees and NPDES permits including MS4 — each describe a cycle in operation, and the recoding_note column records why each of the five was decided as it was, for the two that stayed as well as the three that moved. The durability and outcome codings are unchanged. No score, figure or source has been altered other than the three e5_level values and their accompanying text. Findings 1 · No programme requires evidence integration. Of fourteen streams, none is coded at level 2. Twelve fund no mechanism at all; two fund one partially, and both are partial in the same way — an evidence-revision cycle operates inside a compliance chain and stops at the boundary of planning authority. The distribution across domains is not merely uneven but concentrated in one: two of the three regulatory programmes support a partial mechanism. None of the eleven research, infrastructure, climate or community-development programmes does. Programmes that build ecological capital fund the asset and evaluate its completion; none funds the institutional relationship that would make the asset consequential for a planning decision. 2 · Durability tracked legal form, not scale or performance. Durability class · Survived · Proposed for cut · Curtailed · n L1 Statutory or judicial anchor — 2 · 0 · 0 · 2 L2 Standing institutional anchor — 1 · 1 · 0 · 2 L3 Appropriation-contingent — 2 · 2 · 2 · 6 L4 Project-contingent — 0 · 0 · 4 · 4 None of the four programmes anchored in law or in a standing institution was withdrawn. Of the ten resting on an appropriation or a competitive award, six were curtailed and two more are proposed for elimination or reduction — eight of ten either lost or under threat. The project-contingent category was cleared entirely. The magnitudes make the point concrete: a USD 27 billion programme lost more than USD 16 billion in terminations and, under section 60103, its statutory basis along with its disbursements; over the same period a consent-order obligation running materially over budget and behind schedule was not touched. Nor was the pattern produced by executive action alone — the Section 319 nonpoint source programme, appropriated at USD 174.3 million in the previous fiscal year, was proposed for elimination through the ordinary appropriations process. 3 · Evidence integration is almost entirely absent, and where present it is statutory in origin. Two of the fourteen streams fund a mechanism connecting monitoring findings to programme revision. Both are anchored in law, and both are creatures of the same regulatory regime: a consent order and a permit condition, each enforceable through the Clean Water Act. The remaining twelve fund none. The cross-tabulation is therefore perfectly separated and, read as a correlation, almost uninformative: a two-against-twelve table resting on a single statutory mechanism cannot establish that durability and evidence integration travel together, and it is not offered here as establishing it. What the inventory supports is narrower and firmer. Evidence integration does not appear in federal programme design as a feature a well-constructed grant supplies; where it appears, a statute has imposed it, and the programme has absorbed the requirement rather than chosen it. Field definitions Field · Meaning program_name · administering_agency — Programme and the agency that administers it programme_domain — Research, infrastructure, regulatory, climate, or community development statutory_basis — The Act, section or instrument from which the programme derives authority what_it_funds — The object of the expenditure funds_E5_evidence_integration — Narrative statement of whether and how the programme funds evidence integration e5_level — The coded value, 0–2, per the scheme above durability_layer — Narrative statement of where the spending obligation originates durability_class — The coded value, L1–L4, per the scheme above status_2022_2024 · status_2025_2026 — Programme status before and after the reversal outcome_2025_26 — The coded value per the scheme above ecoull_relevance — How the programme bears on ecology-oriented urban living lab governance source_document · verification_status — Source and the date and basis of verification Verification All fourteen records were verified against primary or contemporaneous sources, most recently on 5 September 2026. The verification_status field records the basis and date for each. One record was corrected on 5 September 2026. The standing federal–municipal research partnership exemplified by the NYC Urban Field Station was previously recorded as an NSF partnership. It is not: the Urban Field Station is a USDA Forest Service Northern Research Station and NYC Parks partnership established in 2006, joined by the Natural Areas Conservancy in 2013, now convening more than ninety partner organisations. NSF supports urban ecological research on a separate footing, through the Urban LTER network. The record and its administering-agency field have been corrected accordingly. Four statuses were live and moving at compilation and were held open until confirmed: USDA Urban and Community Forestry. The Inflation Reduction Act appropriated USD 1.5 billion under section 23003; in September 2023 USDA announced over USD 1 billion in awards to 385 recipients. Awards were frozen in early 2025 and subsequently terminated. On 14 August 2025 a federal court partially granted a preliminary injunction enjoining the termination. Section 10201 of Public Law 119-21 (2025) then rescinded unobligated funds under IRA section 23003(a)(2). The outcome divides cleanly: obligated awards protected by judicial injunction continued, unobligated balances were removed by statute. IIJA coastal resilience and ecosystem restoration. Executive Order 14154 (January 2025) paused disbursement of IIJA- and IRA-appropriated funds. The pause proved partial: NOAA continued to operate IIJA-funded habitat restoration and coastal resilience competitions through 2025. The National Coastal Resilience Fund carries a fixed multi-year statutory allocation — USD 100 million per year for fiscal years 2022 through 2026 — which proved more resistant to executive pause than discretionary supplemental funding. Clean Water Act Section 319. Appropriated at USD 174.3 million in FY2025; the FY2026 EPA budget request proposed eliminating the programme in full. Coded as active but proposed for cut, because the threat arrives through the appropriations process rather than through executive action. NSF Coastlines and People. Coded as closed rather than active: the most recent solicitation, NSF 21-613, closed to proposals on 6 December 2021 and no successor call has been issued. Access Files are openly available under CC BY 4.0 from the date of deposit. The coding scheme, the field definitions and all findings are reproduced in this description, so that the evidentiary basis of the analysis is legible from the record page itself as well as from the files. Relationship to other records in this series This record differs in kind from the others: it is a programme inventory rather than a ULE scoring record, and its unit of analysis is the federal programme rather than the metropolitan jurisdiction. It connects to the series through the E5 condition, whose definition it takes from the codebook. Record · Type · DOI Codebook and scoring protocol — Method · 10.5281/zenodo.21645631 Netherlands and Türkiye — ULE scoring · 10.5281/zenodo.20811366 Istanbul and New York City — ULE scoring · 10.5281/zenodo.21649244 Three US metropolitan regions — ULE scoring · 10.5281/zenodo.21675193 US federal funding mechanisms — Programme inventory · this record Finding 3 above records an absence rather than a relationship. Evidence integration is present in two of fourteen streams, and both are creatures of one statutory regime, so the inventory does not establish that durability and evidence integration travel together and is not offered as establishing it. What it does show is that evidence integration does not arise from programme design on its own. The framework was developed at the metropolitan scale; this record observes a related question at a different unit of analysis, which is why it is deposited separately rather than folded into a scoring record. Reuse The inventory is intended to be useful beyond the associated manuscript. Researchers tracking US climate funding volatility, or examining which federal instruments survived the 2025–2026 reversal, can use it directly. The coding scheme is designed to be extended to further programmes; extensions should cite this record and state whether the durability and evidence-integration codings were assigned independently, and should apply the level-1 definition as written: an evidence-revision cycle that operates, not one that a programme would permit. Citation Çelik Yılmaz, Ö. (2026). US Federal Climate and Ecological Funding Mechanisms: An Institutional Inventory [Data set]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23037941 Funding Prepared with the support of a TÜBİTAK 2218 National Postdoctoral Research Fellowship, on ecology-oriented urban living labs and watershed governance.
Keyword(s):
consent orders; evidence integration; federal climate funding; green infrastructure; institutional durability.
MeSH Term(s):
Grants and Funding:
No Grants or Funding Data Available
Associated Publication(s):
No Associated Publication Data Available
Supplementary Data:
No Supplementary Data Available
Related Dataset(s):
No Related Dataset Data Available
The National Library of Medicine (NLM) provides information about biomedical datasets. Inclusion on an NLM Web page does not imply endorsement of, or agreement with, the contents by NLM or the National Institutes of Health. Learn more: NLM Web Policies (nih.gov)