Loading...
Loading...
Contributors:
Dataset URI:
10.5281/zenodo.23170916# Chernobyl ¹³⁷Cs and neoplasm mortality across Türkiye — data and analysis code **Distinguishing spatial confounding from radiation effects in ecological studies through an apparent Chernobyl–neoplasm mortality gradient across Türkiye** This repository is the reproducibility compendium for the study above. It contains the province-level analytic dataset (81 Turkish provinces, pooled 2018–2024, 53 variables) and a single, self-contained Python pipeline that regenerates every table and figure in the article. **Short summary.** An apparent positive association between modelled Chernobyl-derived caesium-137 (¹³⁷Cs) and province-level neoplasm mortality is shown to be better explained by **spatial confounding** than by radiation. The evidence is a falsification framework: dose reconciliation, sequential (hierarchical) confounder adjustment, negative-control outcomes, an order-invariant (Shapley) decomposition of the sequential adjustment, penalized regression with bootstrap, explicit spatial regression (spatial-error and spatial-lag models, with Lagrange-multiplier diagnostics and spatial-lag impacts), analyses of residual confounding by historical smoking, the E-value, and a ⁹⁰Sr collinearity check. --- ## Repository contents ```.├── README.md This file├── CHANGELOG.md Version history├── CITATION.cff How to cite (Citation File Format)├── .zenodo.json Zenodo deposit metadata├── requirements.txt Exact Python dependencies (Python 3.12)├── LICENSE-CODE-MIT.txt License for the code (MIT)├── LICENSE-DATA-CC-BY-4.0.txt License for the data (CC BY 4.0)├── data/│ ├── data.xlsx Analytic dataset (sheet 'data'; 81 × 53)│ ├── data_dictionary.csv Codebook: variable, description, unit, source, notes│ └── tuik_deaths_by_province_cause_2022_2025.csv TÜİK deaths by province and selected cause (long format; used for the unknown-cause share)├── code/│ ├── chernobyl_neoplasm_analysis.py Single-file analysis pipeline (tables, quick-look figures)│ ├── make_figures.py Publication-quality Figs 1–4 and S1–S4 (reads data.xlsx + ALL_RESULTS.xlsx)│ └── make_figures_colab.ipynb The same figure generator as a Google Colab notebook├── figures/ Publication figures: vector PDF + 300-dpi PNG (600-dpi TIFF written by make_figures.py)└── results/ Reference outputs (regenerated by the script) ├── ALL_RESULTS.xlsx 43 result sheets ├── Fig2_dose_reconciliation.png Dose reconciliation ├── Fig3_negative_control.png Negative-control outcomes ├── Fig4_sequential_attenuation.png Sequential attenuation ├── FigS1_block_order_shapley.png Order-invariant (Shapley) decomposition of the attenuation ├── FigS2_coefficient_paths.png Penalized-regression coefficient paths ├── FigS3_penalized_R2.png Out-of-sample test R² (repeated splits) └── FigS4_moran_lisa.png Moran scatter + LISA quadrant counts``` ## The dataset `data/data.xlsx` (sheet **`data`**) has one row per Turkish province (N = 81) and 53 columns. Full definitions, units, and sources are in **`data/data_dictionary.csv`**. Key fields: - **`NEOP`** — neoplasm mortality (ICD-10 C00–D48), deaths per 100,000, 7-year pooled mean (primary outcome).- **`UNSCEAR_CS137`, `WHO_CS137`** — the exposure. These are **modelled first-year adult effective dose (mSv yr⁻¹)** from Simsek et al. (2014), under UNSCEAR- and WHO-referenced calibrations. **They are NOT deposition densities (kBq m⁻²).** The two calibrations are almost perfectly collinear (r > 0.99) and are used in separate specifications.- **`CHERNOBYL_DISTANCE`** — population-weighted great-circle distance to the Chernobyl NPP (km).- **Confounders central to the analysis** — age-band shares (`AGE_45_54`…`AGE_75_AND_OVER`), `HUMAN_DEVELOPMENT_INDEX`, `GDP`, `EDUCATION`, `UNEMPLOYMENT`, `SMOKING`, `OBESITY` (both available only as current NUTS-1, 12-region, estimates), physician density (`PHYSICIANS_PER_100K` and components), hospital beds (`BEDS_PER100K`), urbanisation (`URBAN_PCT`), and internal migration (`NET_MIGRATION_RATE`, `GROSS_MIGRATION_RATE`).- **Negative-control outcomes** — cause-specific mortality rates `CIRC`, `RESP`, `NEURO`, `ENDOC`, `EXTERNAL`, `COVID`, `OTHER` (per 100,000); `UNKNOWN_DEATH` (unknown-cause deaths, per 100,000) as a registration-quality index.- **`PERSON_YEARS`** — total person-years (Σ 2018–2024 population), the offset for count models. > **Note on two fields.** `UNKNOWN_DEATH` is a registration-quality index whose exact unit (proportion of deaths vs rate per 100,000) should be confirmed against the source; its near-zero correlation with the gradient makes this immaterial to the conclusions. `migration` is a legacy column superseded by `NET_MIGRATION_RATE`/`GROSS_MIGRATION_RATE`. `PM2_5` is incomplete and is not used as a primary covariate. ## How to reproduce Requires **Python 3.12**. ```bash# 1. (optional) create a clean environmentpython -m venv .venv && source .venv/bin/activate # 2. install exact dependenciespip install -r requirements.txt # 3. run the pipelinepython code/chernobyl_neoplasm_analysis.py``` The script auto-locates `data/data.xlsx` and writes outputs to `results/`:`ALL_RESULTS.xlsx` (43 sheets) and eight PNG figures. It prints a detailed log, including a **`Key_numbers`** sheet that lists every headline number for line-by-line cross-checking against the article's tables. **Google Colab.** Upload `data/data.xlsx` to the session, paste the script, and run all. Missing packages (`libpysal`, `esda`, `spreg`) are installed automatically at start-up. ### Publication-quality figures ```bashpython code/make_figures.py # run from the repository root; writes figures/ (PDF, TIFF 600 dpi, PNG 300 dpi)python code/make_figures.py --only fig1 fig4 figS2 # a subset``` `make_figures.py` plots every estimate from `results/ALL_RESULTS.xlsx` (so figures cannot disagree with the tables) and recomputes onlythe figure-specific objects from `data/data.xlsx` (choropleth classes, penalized-regression paths, repeated-split R², Moran scatter). It printsconsistency checks against the stored results (Moran's I, Lasso and Elastic-Net coefficients). Choropleth classes are quintiles of theprovince values. Province boundaries are downloaded from the `cihadturhan/tr-geojson` repository (© OpenStreetMap contributors, ODbL);set `CFG["geo_path"]` to use a local boundary file. In Google Colab either open `code/make_figures_colab.ipynb` and run all cells, or paste the whole of `make_figures.py` into a single cell and run it; missing packages are installed and the two Excel files are requested through an upload dialog automatically. Fonts: Arial if available, otherwise Liberation Sans (metric-compatible). ## What the pipeline computes Descriptive statistics; bivariate and exposure-axis correlations; primary OLS (HC3) and negative-binomial models; ΔR² decomposition; **Moran's I + LISA** and **explicit spatial-error / spatial-lag regression**; **penalized regression (Ridge/Lasso/Elastic-Net) with a 1000-replicate bootstrap**; sequential (hierarchical) adjustment; **dose reconciliation** with a derived first-year→cumulative multiplier and multi-specification observed/expected comparison; a radon dose-tracking negative control; the **E-value**; a **⁹⁰Sr collinearity** demonstration; new-covariate impact; a churn (population-turnover) interaction; registration-quality and detection-capacity robustness; **negative-control outcomes** across seven causes of death (with Benjamini–Hochberg correction) and their coupling to the socio-demographic axis, with a sensitivity analysis excluding the 11 provinces affected by the 6 February 2023 earthquakes (which add external-cause deaths); an **order-invariant decomposition** of the sequential adjustment (all 64 block-subset models, exact Shapley values over 720 orderings, leave-one-block-out); **spatial diagnostics** (Lagrange-multiplier tests, likelihood-ratio/AIC comparison, direct/indirect/total spatial-lag impacts); **historical-smoking** analyses (NUTS-1 fixed effects, flexible specifications, bias analysis); a particulate-matter exclusion sensitivity; a **dose-reconciliation sensitivity** to risk coefficient (including the INWORKS low-dose slope) and DDREF; and a scale-reconciliation table (IRR vs rate-scale vs standardized coefficients). ## Data sources Compiled from public sources: the **Turkish Statistical Institute (TÜİK)** (cause-of-death and population statistics, internal migration, degree-of-urbanisation, socioeconomic indicators); the **Republic of Türkiye Ministry of Health** (Health Statistics Yearbooks: physicians, hospital beds, smoking, obesity); modelled ¹³⁷Cs effective doses from **Simsek et al., *Science of the Total Environment* 499 (2014) 74–88**; a Turkish indoor-radon survey; satellite products (Sentinel-5P/TROPOMI, MODIS). See `data/data_dictionary.csv` for per-variable attribution and the article for full citations. `data/tuik_deaths_by_province_cause_2022_2025.csv` reproduces, in long format, the TÜİK table *Deaths by province and selected causes* (by place of usual residence; source: TÜİK, Death and Causes of Death Statistics, 2025; underlying registers: General Directorate of Civil Registration and Citizenship Affairs and Ministry of Health). Values for 2022–2024 are revised figures (marked `(r)` in the source). ## Licenses - **Code** (`code/`): MIT License — `LICENSE-CODE-MIT.txt`.- **Data** (`data/`): Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 (CC BY 4.0) — `LICENSE-DATA-CC-BY-4.0.txt`. Please also respect the terms of the original data providers listed above. ## How to cite If you use these materials, please cite **both** this deposit and the associated article. A machine-readable citation is in `CITATION.cff`. Example: > Etli, Y., Korkmaz Yalçın, D., Kartal, E., & Aşırdizer, M. (2026). *Distinguishing spatial confounding from radiation effects in ecological studies: Chernobyl ¹³⁷Cs and province-level neoplasm mortality across Türkiye — data and analysis code* (Version 2.1.1) [Data set]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/<insert-DOI> ## Contact Yasin Etli — yasinetli@yyu.edu.tr — Department of Forensic Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Van Yüzüncü Yıl University, Van, Türkiye. ## Disclaimer This is an ecological (province-level) analysis and does not support individual-level causal inference. The study finds **no evidence** that Chernobyl fallout has measurably increased neoplasm mortality in Türkiye and provides no basis for changes to cancer screening or clinical practice.
Keyword(s):
MeSH Term(s):
Grants and Funding:
No Grants or Funding Data Available
Associated Publication(s):
No Associated Publication Data Available
Supplementary Data:
No Supplementary Data Available
Related Dataset(s):
No Related Dataset Data Available
The National Library of Medicine (NLM) provides information about biomedical datasets. Inclusion on an NLM Web page does not imply endorsement of, or agreement with, the contents by NLM or the National Institutes of Health. Learn more: NLM Web Policies (nih.gov)