Loading...
Loading...
Contributors:
Dataset URI:
10.5281/zenodo.234815550.1.4 (19 October 2026): the citations files also give a citation identifier built from its content, the CLIMPACT codes of the citing document and of the citing case, the country as an ISO 3166 code, the court from the CLIMPACT list of courts with its level, the language of the citing document and the precision of its date.Influence, rule N01 (beta), and the TRACE Judicial Impact Index. Each citing case is placed on the highest of four steps its citations reach (R1 mentioned, R2 argued by a party, R3 named by a court, R4 relied on by a court in its reasoning). The index sums the citing cases with the weights ¼, ½, ¾ and 1, the expected values of every weighting that keeps the order of the steps; its 90% range counts the machine's reading errors, the sampling of cases and the weights. For Urgenda the index is 79.0 (54.2 to 108.3) and the cases where a court relies on it, corrected for reading errors, are 37 (27 to 48). The index does not replace reach, mobilisation and judicial reception, which stay next to it, and it does not rank the judgments. It is also given without the filings of United States courts, as a test of robustness. Speed, half-life and the principles that travel are experimental. Coming in later versions: the citations among the citing cases (extraction from 14 October 2026) with centrality measures, a blind check of 80 citations drawn at random, and the half-life of the younger judgments.The citations found by CLIMPACT TRACE 0.1 in later climate litigation. TRACE is a method to trace how climate judgments are received in later litigation, for any judgment; its first release applies it to the climate judgments and advisory opinions it follows: Urgenda, Neubauer, Future Generations, KlimaSeniorinnen, the ICJ advisory opinion on climate change and the Inter-American Court advisory opinion OC-32/25. One row per citation, with the citing document, court, country, page, what the citation does with the judgment, who makes it, the principles taken up, the cited paragraphs, the nearby pages where the argument continues, the citing sentence and passage, and the version codes of the steps that made each proposal. The proposals come from DeepSeek V4 Flash, a large language model with open weights run by the project at ReCaS-Bari: each citation is read five times and the majority decides (R11, Proposals by majority vote of five readings); the version codes L are its readings.What TRACE is for. TRACE brings to the surface what no research team could find by reading alone: every citation of the climate judgments it follows, across hundreds of later filings and thousands of pages, each with the sentence that carries it and a proposal of what it does, and hands it to the people who decide. People stay at its centre. Its strength is the pipeline. It stacks many layers on top of one another: name searches, paragraph maps, rules, five independent readings, models trained on the team's judgments, and a version code on every step. Each layer is measured, and every proposal can be traced back to the exact words on the page and the exact version that produced it. That order is what made these results possible with just over 400 citations judged by people. This first release is a beta, and a starting point, not a ceiling. Every new human judgment enters a pipeline that is already ordered and traceable to the smallest piece, and becomes clean training data, so each one makes the next model better informed. TRACE 0.2 will measure how far that takes it.Computing and energy. TRACE 0.1 used 1,355 GPU-hours on NVIDIA H100 GPUs at ReCaS-Bari (25 September to 9 October 2026), about 0.8 to 1.5 MWh at the level of the data centre on a literature range of PUE, since ReCaS does not publish its own; the technical report gives the method and its limits.A beta under verification. TRACE 0.1 is a beta release that the CLIMPACT research team is verifying, for all the judgments it follows: at release, 414 of the 7,893 citations have been verified by the team (and 16 discarded), and the others are machine proposals, made from the readings of DeepSeek V4 Flash, as the field review_status says. Do not present a proposal as a finding. See README.md and the technical report.Next: TRACE 0.2. The whole corpus read again with our own reasoning reranker, trained on our team's judgments and released open with TRACE 0.1.Source: the Climate Litigation Database (climatecasechart.com), read through its public API. Data provided by the Sabin Center for Climate Change Law. Platform operated by Climate Policy Radar. Following the Center's terms, the dataset is released under CC BY-NC 4.0. The code and models are a separate record: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23275400.CLIMPACT is a Starting Grant funded under FIS 3 (Fondo Italiano per la Scienza), CUP H53C25000820001.
Keyword(s):
citation analysis; climate litigation; CLIMPACT; dataset; Future Generations.
MeSH Term(s):
Grants and Funding:
No Grants or Funding Data Available
Associated Publication(s):
No Associated Publication Data Available
Supplementary Data:
Related Dataset(s):
No Related Dataset Data Available
The National Library of Medicine (NLM) provides information about biomedical datasets. Inclusion on an NLM Web page does not imply endorsement of, or agreement with, the contents by NLM or the National Institutes of Health. Learn more: NLM Web Policies (nih.gov)